After a busy fall trying to balance a full time job, taking classes, and keeping to my track coach’s training schedule, I knew that I wanted to take some time during the holiday season to get away. Living in the northeast, my first choice is always New York. When I think about going out of town, my thoughts immediately turn to what food I might be able to eat and explore while I am there. New York has so much to offer, from what you find at the market, to the seemingly endless number of high end restaurants, to the equally unique and special “cheap eats” that are essential to survival for one in my position. On this trip to New York, I would be spending some time with family, some time with friends, and some time exploring the city on my own (mostly in the morning when friends were asleep and I would sneak out for a couple hours…). My parents were kind enough to take me out to dinner at places I cannot afford due to the ever dwindling bank account of a college student, and this added to the excitement of the trip. Meals included dinner at Michael Psilakis’ Anthos, a seafood centered, Greek inspired restaurant a block and a half from Bobby Flay’s Bar Americain (just an example of the culinary power that is so prevalent in the city), dinner at Ouest on the Upper West Side, New Year’s brunch at Norma’s at the Parker Meridien, breakfast at Shopsin’s in the Essex Street Market on the Lower East Side, and dinner at the new and highly acclaimed Marea. I would have felt lucky to dine at just one of these establishments on my trip to the city, so being able to visit them all felt like somewhat of a miracle. Even more unbelievable is the list of places in the city where I hope to eat in the future, and how this list managed not to reduce in size after this trip, but to grow…
In addition to the meals I enjoyed with family, I was also on my own (with a friend) for a great number of meals. I had saved some money from my work this fall in anticipation of this trip, but for the most part I attempted to restrain myself as I wandered the streets in a state of wonder and amazement. It seems strange to speak of these feelings while waiting for a subway, watching the rats scurry across the tracks, but I had moments while exploring the streets when I was struck by all this city has to offer for someone as captivated with food as I am. During the rest of my time in the city I ate at falafel “joints,” I ate at Barney Greengrass and Kefi (another Michael Psilakis establishment) on the Upper West Side, and I ventured to the Lower East Side to try David Chang’s pork buns at 9am. I met friends for lunch at Ocean Grill and enjoyed (maybe a little too much) a late night trip to Minetta Tavern. I also spent some time at a number of different markets where I would discover some new foods ingredients, some of which I am very glad I did.
The trip had so many high points, and not all came along with the high price tags. I had a smoked Sturgeon appetizer at Ouest which brought exactly what I had wanted. I never ate smoked sturgeon before this trip to New York, and I knew that New York City was where I wanted to try it. I expected to find what I was looking for at Zabar’s or a deli, somewhere that specializes in in this kind of thing, but I found the sample I had purchased at Zabar’s to be lacking. The flavor was slightly fishy and lacked a noticeable smoke. The appetizer at Ouest however, far exceeded my expectations. Being in a high end restaurant, the dish was more refined, served with frisee, a poached egg, and lardons, but what accompanied the dish was not what defined it. The sturgeon had a velvety texture and retained a certain fresh quality in addition to a gentle smoke.
On a previous trip to New York, I visited Taim Falafel and Smoothie Bar. I had a falafel sandwich and tried each of their three flavors of falafel. They have a green falafel with parsley, cilantro, and mint, a roasted red pepper falafel, and a harissa spiced falafel, all of which I enjoyed the flavor of. One late morning while I wandered the city alone, I stopped by for an early lunch and decided to try their Sabich Sandwich. The sandwich is served in a pita and includes slices of fried eggplant, a sliced hard-boiled egg, hummus, Israeli salad, marinated cabbage, tahini, and a mango chutney. It sounded like a lot to me, but I found that when eating it, something was added to the experience by each ingredient. The fried eggplant was meaty and flavorful. The hard-boiled egg added to the “meatiness” but contributed a subtle eggy flavor that was not at all overwhelming. The Israeli salad and cabbage added freshness and crunch. The hummus and tahini added great flavor and creaminess, and the mango chutney added a touch of sweetness. Over all, it was a very satisfying sandwich, and for six dollars, it was certainly a highlight of the trip.
Also a highlight of the trip was an unexpected late night trip to Minetta Tavern. A friend of mine and I had split a couple bottles of wine and had two rounds of drinks at the bars before we made it to an eleven o’clock showing of Fantastic Mr. Fox. The movie was fairly entertaining, but I decided midway through the film that I was going to borrow my friends phone and look up somewhere to find good late night food during the middle of the week. I ended up on the Minetta Tavern website, and their closing time was listed as 2am. I had heard so much about their Black Label Burger, and could not think of anything I might want more than to have a great burger experience. I have spent some time looking for this experience in the past, and I always manage to some up short of what I hope. We get out of the movie at 12:30am and hop on the L train to Washington Square Park, three blocks from Minetta Tavern. We were not concerned about time, and this was nearly a problem. We made our way to the door at 12:55am, only to see that the listed closing time was 1am… The man at the door confused us for drunk college students who had made their way across the street from Mamoun’s Falafel, so we informed him that we were actually looking for a table. The hostess saw us come in and immediately sat us down, as the kitchen would be closing in five minutes. I ordered quickly for both my friend and me. I told him this was to be my treat, and I quickly grabbed his menu away. I ordered two appetizers, squid stuffed with salt cod, piquillo pepper, olives, and preserved lemon, and a trio of tartares, one beef, one lamb, and one veal. The appetizers were much enjoyed. The filling in the squid was excellent and made of for the fairly chewy exterior. The tartares were great. Each had a distinct flavor, and the texture was perfect. None of the three were the least bit chewy, and all had good “mouth feel.” Next we had the Black Label Burger. I had not ventured out for a burger in quite a while. I was a little sick of coming up short of my expectations so consistently. This time would be different. The burger was mix of prime dry-aged beef loosely held together by its own fat. It came on a custom made brioche bun and was served with caramelized onions. I am a big fan of caramelized onions, and I appreciate the sweetness they bring to any burger. The brioche bun was buttery and soft, very light and did not have as much sweetness as an ordinary brioche. But this burger was all about the meat. It had a nice crust and was thick and juicy. It was meltingly tender, a result of both the dry aged beef and the fat that had melted into it. The meet had a superb beefy flavor and an almost nutty quality that can only be obtained through careful dry-aging. I savored each bite, and though time has passed since, I still feel as though I can just barely taste that last bite. The memory remains on the tip of my tongue, although it is unfortunately not accompanied by the satisfaction that was in the moment. The only shared feeling is one of longing. I cannot wait until I can have the burger again, or at least another like it, wherever it may be. I had begun to doubt that I would find such a satisfying burger, but this trip gave me hope. I was not dreaming of some unattainable beast.
These highlights made the trip great, but there was so much more food that added to the experience. I had great food all over the city, and I will post about some of the experience soon. I may also get to some of the disappointments I came across. While exploring any great food city, these disappointments are inevitable. But don’t get me wrong, the positives I found far outweighed the negative, and I can’t wait to do it again.
Posted by guiltygourmet